Ohio Player of the Year (1)
2009 Chris Pohlman - Defensive Player of the Year (Junior)

Ohio 1st Team (6)
2009 Tyler Bergfeld - Defensive Back (Junior)
2009 Jordan Leininger - Running Back (Junior)
2009 Chris Pohlman - Linebacker (Junior)
2009 Alex Recker - Center (Junior)
2008 Tyler Hayson - Defensive Line (Senior)
2005 Michael Grubenhoff - Linebacker (Senior)

Ohio 2nd Team (3)
2009 Derek Klaus - Defensive End (Junior)
2008 AJ Klausing - Defensive Back (Sophomore)
2008 Chris Pohlman - Linebacker (Sophomore)

Ohio Player of the Year (By Position)
1 Defensive Player of the Year

Ohio 1st Team (By Position)
2 Linebacker
1 Center
1 Defensive Back
1 Defensive Line
1 Running Back

Ohio 2nd Team (By Position)
1 Defensive Back
1 Defensive End
1 Linebacker