|  | Season | Result | Notes | 
                
		  | A | 2024-25 | W | 75-47							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 18 Losses: 8 Division IV
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Ryan Howard
 Tournament: Division IV Regional Semi-Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2023-24 | L | 47-54							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 16 Losses: 8 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Matt Tabler
 Tournament: Division II District Semi-Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2022-23 | W | 57-37							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 9 Losses: 15 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Matt Tabler
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2021-22 | W | 49-36							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 3 Losses: 20 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Matt Tabler
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2020-21 | W | 61-27							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 5 Losses: 17 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2019-20 | W | 54-52							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 8 Losses: 16 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2018-19 | W | 40-37							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 14 Losses: 11 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II District Semi-Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2017-18 | L | 44-50							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 18 Losses: 5 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2016-17 | W | 48-45							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 17 Losses: 10 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II Regional Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2015-16 | W | 51-42							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 10 Losses: 15 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II District Semi-Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2014-15 | W | 56-46							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 10 Losses: 13 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II District Semi-Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2013-14 | L | 40-52							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 21 Losses: 4 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League Co-Champs
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II District Finalist
 
 | (moved from 12/7) | 
                
		  | A | 2012-13 | W | 49-44							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 17 Losses: 9 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League Co-Champs
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II District Finalist
 
 | Elida: Dakota Mathias - Purdue commit | 
                
		  | H | 2011-12 | L | 49-58							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 24 Losses: 4 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League Co-Champ
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II State Runner-up
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2010-11 | L | 24-39							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 13 Losses: 9 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 
 | (moved from 12/11) | 
                
		  | H | 2009-10 | W | 50-42							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 13 Losses: 10 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II District Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2008-09 | W | 49-46							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 16 Losses: 9 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 Tournament: Division II Regional Semi-Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2007-08 | W | 52-49							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 7 Losses: 13 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2006-07 | L | 44-58							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 7 Losses: 15 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Denny Thompson
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2005-06 | W | 54-39							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Wins: 16 Losses: 6 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League Champs
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division II District Semi-Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2004-05 | L | 54-67							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 17 Losses: 4 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 2003-04 | W | 39-36							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Wins: 13 Losses: 9 Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 | TV-44 | 
                
		  | A | 2002-03 | L | 58-72							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League Quad-Champ
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division II District Finalist
 
 | TV-25 | 
                
		  | H | 2001-02 | W | 52-44							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 2000-01 | L | 60-70							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 1999-00 | W | 47-39							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 1998-99 | L | 46-62							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division II District Finalist
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 1997-98 | L | 46-48							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League Tri-Champ
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division II District Finalist
 
 | TV-44 | 
                
		  | A | 1996-97 | W | 56-50							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division II Regional Participant
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 1995-96 | W | 55-41							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Division I
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 1994-95 | L | 48-65							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Division I
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division I District Participant
 
 |  | 
                
		  | H | 1993-94 | L | 63-66							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 1992-93 | L | 63-79							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  Mark Spieles 21 pts, Aaron Sever 16 pts Elida: Maxwell 31 pts
 | 
                
		  | H | 1991-92 | W | 80-78							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  Scott Elwer 38 pts, Jeff Wieging and Keith Jackson 10 pts Elida: 6-9 Jon Wooley 37 pts, Barrington 22 pts
 | 
                
		  | A | 1990-91 | L | 57-81							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Division I
 League: Western Buckeye League Champs
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division I District Participant
 
 |  Scott Elwer 17 pts, Jeff Sever and Kurt Gunder 10 pts Elida: Curry 23 pts
 | 
                
		  | H | 1989-90 | W | 87-70							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Division I
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division I District Participant
 
 |  Steve Jettinghoff 30 pts, Pat McGue 18 pts, Jeff Sever 15 pts Elida: Curry 27 pts
 | 
                
		  | A | 1988-89 | W | 70-67							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  Curt Mager 26 pts 5 3's, Doug Etgen 17 pts, Duane Grothause 12 pts Elida: May 21 pts, Curry 20 pts
 | 
                
		  | H | 1987-88 | L | 69-74							
				  				  TOpponent Info: Division II
 League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 Tournament: Division II Regional Qualifier
 
 |  Doug Etgen 17 pts, Mike Williams 14 pts, Brian Heitz 13 pts, Duane Grothause 11 pts Elida: Good 26 pts
 | 
                
		  | A | 1986-87 | L | 61-69							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League Tri-Champ
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  Mike Williams 27 pts, Brian Heitz 14 pts Elida: Tom Neider 24 pts
 | 
                
		  | H | 1985-86 | W | 51-43							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 Coach: Chris Adams
 
 |  Mark Wurst 20 pts, Brian Heitz 12 pts, Steve Fortner 10 pts Elida: Hollar 24 pts
 | 
                
		  | A | 1984-85 | W | 69-65							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  Mark Wurst 30 pts, Tim Geise 20 pts, Tony Odenweller 13 pts Elida: Smith 24 pts
 | 
                
		  | H | 1983-84 | W | 76-55							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  Larry, Tim, and Kevin Geise all 18 pts Elida: Patton 22 pts
 | 
                
		  |  | 1982-83 | W | 78-38							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1981-82 | W | 88-42							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1980-81 | W | 87-60							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League Quad Champ
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1979-80 | W | 48-22							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  | ONU | 1978-79+ | W | 56-43							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Class AA
 League: Western Buckeye League
 
 | (Sectional Final) | 
                
		  |  | 1978-79 | W | 68-63							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: Class AA
 League: Western Buckeye League
 
 | (OT) | 
                
		  |  | 1977-78 | W | 76-53							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1976-77 | W | 69-53							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1975-76 | W | 92-60							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1974-75 | W | 84-62							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1973-74 | L | 53-54							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1972-73 | L | 80-87							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1971-72 | W | 96-73							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Western Buckeye League
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1970-71 | W | 86-85							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1969-70 | W | 100-75							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 |  | 
                
		  |  | 1967-68+ | W | 76-70							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 | (Sectional) | 
                
		  |  | 1963-64+ | W | 76-71							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 | (Sectional) | 
                
		  | Lima Senior | 1962-63+ | W | 88-64							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 | (Sectional) Coach Arnzen's 200th victory | 
                
		  | Celina | 1949-50+ | W | 69-52							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 | (District) | 
                
		  |  | 1949-50 | W | 67-49							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 1948-49 | W | 74-43							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 | Dave Schmelzer 32 points | 
                
		  | H | 1947-48 | W | 59-37							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 |  | 
                
		  | A | 1946-47 | W | 40-36							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Northwest Conference
 
 |  | 
                
		  | Lima Shawnee | 1938-39+ | W | 61-27							
				  				  OIOpponent Info: League: Allen County League
 
 | (Sectional) | 
                
		  | Lima Central | 1923-24+ | W | 41-2 | (Sectional) Elida two free throws |